当前,“十点计划”的真实性在美国与伊朗之间正在进行的停火谈判中(截至 2026 年 4 月 9 日)成为主要争议点。白宫、伊朗政府以及主要媒体之间的叙述相互矛盾。
相互冲突的说法
- 特朗普政府的立场: 特朗普总统明确表示,某些媒体报道的“十点计划”版本是“完全虚假的”骗局。白宫新闻秘书 Karoline Leavitt 表示,伊朗确实提出过一个初步的十点计划,但被美国谈判团队视为“伊朗的愿望清单”,并“直接被扔进垃圾桶”。
- 媒体报道: 《纽约时报》和 CNN 等媒体报道了一份十点提案,其中据称包括解除制裁和美军撤离等让步。特朗普指责这些媒体引用了来自尼日利亚的“假新闻网站”的信息。
- 伊朗的立场: 伊朗国家媒体和国家最高安全委员会公开分享了一份十点计划,声称这是当前停火协议的基础。
关键报道内容(存在争议)
被称为“假”的版本据称包含一些美国方面坚称未接受的高风险要求,包括:
- 霍尔木兹海峡: 伊朗继续控制或收取通行费。
- 核计划: 接受伊朗继续进行铀浓缩。
- 军事存在: 美国从该地区撤军。
- 经济缓解: 全面解除美国制裁。
停火现状
4 月 7 日宣布了为期两周的停火,以便在巴基斯坦伊斯兰堡进行正式和平谈判。美国承认确实存在一个十点提案,可作为讨论的“可行基础”,但坚持认为媒体流传的具体版本不准确,也不代表正在私下谈判的实际条款。
The validity of the "10-point plan" is currently a major point of contention in ongoing ceasefire negotiations between the U.S. and Iran (as of April 9, 2026). The situation is defined by conflicting narratives from the White House, the Iranian government, and major media outlets.
The Conflicting Claims
- Trump Administration’s Position: President Trump has explicitly labeled certain reported versions of a "10-point plan" as a "totally fake" hoax. White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt stated that while Iran did propose an initial 10-point plan, it was "literally thrown in the garbage" by the U.S. negotiating team for being an "Iranian wishlist".
- Media Reporting: Outlets like The New York Times and CNN reported on a 10-point proposal that allegedly included concessions like the lifting of sanctions and U.S. troop withdrawals. Trump accused these outlets of relying on a "fake news site" in Nigeria for their information.
- Iran’s Position: Iranian state media and the Supreme National Security Council have publicly shared a 10-point plan, claiming it was the basis for the current ceasefire.
Key Reported Elements (Contested)
The "fake" plan allegedly included several high-stakes demands that the U.S. insists it has not accepted:
- Strait of Hormuz: Continued Iranian control or toll collection.
- Nuclear Program: Acceptance of continued uranium enrichment.
- Military Presence: Withdrawal of U.S. troops from the region.
- Economic Relief: Full lifting of U.S. sanctions.
Status of the Ceasefire
A two-week ceasefire was announced on April 7, 2026, to allow for formal peace talks in Islamabad, Pakistan. While the U.S. acknowledges that a 10-point proposal exists as a "workable basis" for discussion, they maintain that the specific version circulating in the media is inaccurate and does not represent the actual terms being negotiated privately.